The High-Risk Nature of M&A
M&A transactions compress years of operational and legal risk into a single event. Shareholder disputes, regulatory scrutiny, employment claims, and deal-breaker liabilities often surface precisely when companies are most vulnerable: during change of control.
-
Why it matters: A single uninsured claim can derail closing, wipe out sale proceeds, or leave directors and officers personally exposed.
-
Positioning: Insurance at this stage isn’t just a cost - it’s deal protection.
Asset vs Stock Sale
How a deal is structured - asset purchase vs. stock purchase (or merger) - fundamentally changes which liabilities transfer, who bears responsibility for legacy exposures, and how insurance must be configured at closing.
Early Alignment
We review SPA language and diligence requirements up front to eliminate last-minute surprises.
Benchmarking
We compare tail costs, limits, and terms against market norms so you don’t overpay.
Negotiation
We negotiate change-of-control waivers, tail terms, and coverage continuity directly with underwriters.
Integration
We coordinate with CFOs, GCs, lenders, and deal counsel to ensure insurance isn’t the bottleneck in closing.
Transparency
We explain not just what coverage you need, but why - and how it fits into your deal economics.
How URM Executes
In M&A, insurance isn’t just protection - it’s execution. Deals fall apart when coverage is misunderstood, delayed, or misaligned with the SPA. At URM, we step in early to structure coverage that keeps transactions moving forward.
Operational Coverage Continuity
While transactional coverages handle the high-stakes risks, the so-called “boring lines” of insurance - General Liability, Property, Workers’ Compensation, Crime, and Fiduciary Liability - can quietly derail a closing if overlooked. Buyers, lenders, and landlords expect seamless continuity of these programs from Day One.
Why It Matters
-
Asset sales require buyers to bind new operational coverages immediately, since the seller’s policies generally don’t transfer.
-
Stock sales/mergers may carry policies forward, but change-of-control provisions or carrier cancellations can still create gaps.
-
Third-party contracts (leases, vendor agreements, employee benefit plans) often require uninterrupted coverage.
Key Coverages to Watch
-
General Liability & Auto: Ensure new entities are added to policies without gaps that could invalidate leases or vendor contracts.
-
Workers’ Compensation: Confirm state filings are updated and new employer entities are properly insured.
-
Property & Business Interruption: Verify values, locations, and waiting periods transfer correctly in TSAs (Transition Services Agreements).
-
Crime Insurance: Discovery triggers can leave buyers unprotected for legacy fraud. Coverage should be tailored to avoid disputes.
-
Fiduciary Liability: Protects plan fiduciaries during benefits transitions and plan mergers - often overlooked until a claim arises.
Common Pitfalls
-
Failing to bind buyer coverage early in asset deals, leaving operations uninsured at closing.
-
Missing named insured changes in stock deals, invalidating lessor or lender requirements.
-
Overlooking discovery coverage for Crime or Cyber policies, leaving gaps for legacy claims.
Director & Officer Liability
No group faces more scrutiny during an acquisition than the board and executive team. Every decision they made before closing - from fundraising to governance to disclosures - can become the basis of a lawsuit after the deal is done. Without the right D&O structure, selling shareholders and directors risk being pulled back into litigation long after they’ve moved on.
Why D&O Matters in M&A
-
Pre-close decisions under the microscope – Claims tied to securities offerings, capital raises, board approvals, or governance disputes often surface after closing.
-
Personal liability exposure – Directors and officers can be sued individually for breach of fiduciary duty or misrepresentation.
-
Buyer expectations – Most SPAs explicitly require proof of a D&O tail to ensure legacy leadership is protected.
What Buyers Look For
-
A 6-year D&O tail policy, running off the seller’s existing program, covering pre-close acts only.
-
Adequate limits of liability that reflect deal size, industry, and litigation environment.
-
Confirmation that coverage is non-cancellable and prepaid at closing.
Negotiation Points
-
Who pays for the tail? Sellers and buyers often negotiate cost allocation. Market practice: sellers fund it out of proceeds, but buyers sometimes step in to secure closing certainty.
-
Limit adequacy – Tail limits should be benchmarked against peer deals to avoid under-insurance.
-
Side A protection – Adding a dedicated Side A layer ensures directors are covered even if the company cannot indemnify.
Insurance Requirements in Sale & Purchase Agreements (SPAs)
Insurance isn’t just a back-office detail in M&A - it’s often written directly into the Sale & Purchase Agreement (SPA) as a closing condition. Most SPAs set minimum insurance standards the seller must meet, and buyers (and their lenders) are scrutinizing these requirements with increasing rigor.
The wrong coverage or a gap discovered late in diligence may:
-
Delay funding,
-
Force renegotiation of terms, or
-
In worst cases, derail the deal entirely.
Directors & Officers (D&O) Insurance
-
Shields selling shareholders, directors, and executives from claims tied to their stewardship of the company prior to closing.
-
Buyers want assurance that pre-close decisions (capital raises, board approvals, governance disputes) won’t bleed into post-close liability.
-
Critical detail: Most SPAs require proof of a 6-year D&O tail policy to guarantee protection well beyond the closing date. Premiums typically run 150–250% of the expiring annual premium.
Representations & Warranties (R&W) Insurance
-
Transfers the risk of breaches of reps or warranties in the SPA from the seller to the insurer.
-
Common in mid-market and PE-backed deals where indemnity escrows are heavily negotiated.
-
Strategic value:
-
Sellers achieve a cleaner exit with less capital tied up in escrow.
-
Buyers gain a reliable recovery source without suing the seller.
-
-
Increasingly viewed as standard practice in competitive auction processes.
Cyber & Technology Errors & Omissions (E&O)
-
A deal gatekeeper for regulated, financial, and data-driven businesses.
-
Buyers and lenders often require proof of active Cyber and Tech E&O coverage before releasing funds, particularly where customer contracts, SLAs, or regulatory obligations are involved.
-
Change-of-control wrinkle: Standard Cyber and Tech E&O policies terminate automatically at acquisition. Buyers frequently require sellers to secure a waiver of change-in-control or negotiate continuity of coverage to avoid unintended gaps.
Employment Practices Liability (EPL) Insurance
-
Often overlooked, but critical in deals involving workforce changes.
-
Protects against claims tied to layoffs, retention disputes, and discrimination - issues that often spike immediately post-close.
-
Market norm: Sellers should secure a 6-year EPL tail for pre-close acts. Premiums typically run 150–250% of the expiring annual premium.
Asset Sale
In an asset sale, the buyer typically acquires only selected assets (contracts, IP, customer relationships) while leaving behind the selling entity and its historical liabilities.
That means:
-
The seller remains exposed to pre-closing risks - making D&O and EPL tail coverage critical.
-
The buyer needs to secure new operational coverage (Cyber, E&O, GL) tied to the acquired assets, since existing policies will not carry over.
-
Negotiation often centers on indemnities and whether certain contingent risks (tax, litigation, regulatory) should be ring-fenced with transactional risk insurance.
Mergers & Acquisitions
At the Peak of Risk, Precision Coverage Matters Most
Stock Sale
In a stock sale or merger, the buyer acquires the entity itself - including all of its liabilities, known and unknown. That creates a very different insurance profile:
-
Historical risks come along with the purchase, so the buyer must confirm that existing insurance programs remain valid post-closing (or are properly replaced).
-
Change-of-control provisions are especially critical - many Cyber, Tech E&O, and even D&O policies terminate automatically unless specifically waived or extended.
-
Buyers often rely on R&W insurance and tax liability insurance to protect deal value against undiscovered exposures that surface after closing.
Employment Practices Liability (EPL) in M&A
M&A transactions are one of the leading triggers for employment-related claims. Acquisitions often mean leadership changes, workforce reductions, or shifts in compensation and benefits - fertile ground for litigation. Without the right EPL structure, sellers and buyers alike face exposure to costly disputes.
Why EPL Matters in M&A
-
Layoffs & restructuring – Wrongful termination, discrimination, and retaliation claims frequently spike after closing.
-
Retention disputes – Allegations around severance, bonuses, and employment contracts are common in the deal context.
-
Wage & hour risk – Claims tied to overtime, misclassification, and pay equity can surface when a new owner audits employment practices.
Seller-Side Protection
-
Sellers should secure a 6-year EPL tail to cover pre-close acts.
-
Typical cost: 150–250% of the expiring annual premium.
-
EPL tails are often negotiated in the SPA - deciding whether sellers or buyers fund the coverage.
Buyer-Side Considerations
-
Buyers inherit the ongoing workforce risk. A robust EPL policy should be in place on Day One to cover post-close claims.
-
Buyers must confirm that the acquired entity’s historical EPL claims will be picked up by the seller’s tail, avoiding disputes over which policy responds.
-
Integration planning should include review of handbooks, employment contracts, and benefits transitions - all common claim flashpoints.
What Tail Coverage Provides
-
Extends the seller’s D&O and EPL policies for a fixed period (commonly 6 years) post-closing.
-
Covers claims made after the transaction but tied to conduct that occurred before closing.
-
Creates certainty for directors, officers, shareholders, and managers who want to exit without lingering liability.
Market Norms
-
D&O Tail: Typically 6 years; prepaid in full at closing. Premiums run 150–250% of the expiring annual premium.
-
EPL Tail: Also 6 years; premiums usually 150–250% of the annual premium. Especially important if workforce reductions are expected.
-
Limits: Tails generally preserve the same aggregate limits as the expiring program.
-
Non-cancellable: Once purchased, the tail cannot be revoked or altered.
Key Negotiation Points
-
Who pays? – Sellers often fund the tail from deal proceeds, but in competitive processes buyers sometimes agree to cover the cost for certainty.
-
Adequacy of limits – Benchmarked against deal size, industry risk, and litigation environment. Cutting limits to save cost can undermine protection.
-
Scope of EPL tail – Ensure coverage includes wage & hour defense, retaliation, and discrimination claims, which are common post-close.
Cyber & Technology E&O Continuity
For technology-driven or data-sensitive businesses, Cyber and Technology Errors & Omissions (E&O) insurance is a deal-critical coverage. These policies don’t automatically carry over in an acquisition - in fact, most terminate outright at change of control. Without proper planning, the acquired entity could find itself uninsured the moment the deal closes.
Why Continuity Matters
-
Customer contracts and SLAs often require uninterrupted Cyber/E&O coverage.
-
Regulatory obligations (privacy, data security, financial services oversight) can be breached if coverage lapses.
-
Lenders and buyers increasingly make proof of active Cyber/E&O coverage a closing condition.
The Change-of-Control Problem
-
Standard Cyber and E&O policies contain automatic termination clauses triggered by acquisition.
-
Without endorsements, all coverage ceases at closing - leaving both buyer and seller exposed.
Solutions
-
Waiver of Change in Control – Negotiated with the incumbent insurer to allow the policy to remain in force after acquisition.
-
Discovery Tail (Runoff) – Provides coverage for claims made after closing but tied to pre-close acts. Useful if a waiver isn’t available.
-
Day-One Buyer Coverage – The buyer must ensure its own Cyber/E&O program is structured to pick up the acquired entity immediately post-close.
Negotiation Points
-
Confirm whether the seller or buyer is responsible for securing the waiver or tail in the SPA.
-
Benchmark waiver/tail costs early - carriers vary significantly.
-
Align Cyber/E&O continuity with contractual obligations so customers and regulators aren’t left with gaps.
Representations & Warranties (R&W) Insurance
-
Transfers the risk of breaches of reps and warranties in the SPA from seller to insurer.
-
Standard in mid-market and PE-backed deals where sellers want a clean exit and buyers need certainty of recovery.
-
Reduces or eliminates the need for escrow holdbacks - freeing up capital for sellers and speeding distributions to investors.
Tax Liability Insurance
-
Protects against identified tax exposures (e.g., NOL carryforwards, Section 338 elections, state nexus issues).
-
Often deployed when a single tax risk could derail or materially affect deal economics.
-
Coverage can be written for known, specific issues or more broadly as a buyer comfort tool.
Contingent Risk / Litigation Insurance
-
Addresses known but hard-to-quantify exposures, such as ongoing litigation, contract disputes, or regulatory investigations.
-
Allows buyers to ring-fence liabilities the seller won’t retain.
-
Provides a solution for “hot potato” risks that could otherwise kill a deal.
Environmental / Pollution Legal Liability (PLL) Insurance
-
Critical in deals involving real estate, manufacturing, distribution, or historical operations.
-
Covers cleanup costs, regulatory penalties, and third-party claims arising from pollution conditions - whether known or discovered post-close.
-
Can be structured as a buyer safeguard or as a seller tool to remove legacy risk from negotiations.
Buy-Side vs. Sell-Side Insurance Considerations
Every M&A deal splits the world into two risk profiles: the buyer (who inherits future risk) and the seller (who carries legacy liability). Insurance must be structured to reflect which side of the table you’re on.
Sell-Side Risk
-
Legacy liability: directors, officers, and shareholders are most exposed to claims alleging misconduct, misrepresentation, or breach of fiduciary duty prior to closing.
-
Post-closing, sellers need runoff/tail coverage on D&O and EPL to ensure claims that arise later are still covered.
-
Sellers benefit from R&W insurance because it limits their ongoing indemnification obligations and accelerates clean exits.
Buy-Side Risk
-
Buyers inherit ongoing operational risk (Cyber, E&O, General Liability, Workers’ Comp, etc.).
-
Diligence must confirm policies are in force, transferable, and free of change-of-control termination clauses.
-
In stock purchases especially, buyers step into the seller’s liability footprint — making R&W insurance and continuity of coverage critical.
-
Buyers also use insurance to protect deal value (R&W, tax indemnity, contingent liability coverages).